Blindspot: Mobile browsing

Yesterday, I had a great, if
rushed, conversation with Nokia’s Browser Master, Franklin Davis (nice bio on this page).
Franklin has been deep into mobile browser and Web technologies for a
very long time and I like to go to him for insight into where things
are going. His big thing now is the Nokia Open Source S60 Browser that is based on the same code as Safari from Apple. I’ve
been using the browser on my N93, but it’s also available on a
bunch of other more recent S60 phones, if are lucky enough to get one.
It’s really the fullest browser on a mobile, allowing you to do a lot
more than most PC-based browsers only a few years ago.

But,
here comes my blindspot*: As you may have noticed from reading my site,
I am not too fond of passive mobile browsing or content consumption.
And, talking to Franklin, I was wondering how to put my thoughts in a
positive light, since he’s a ‘browser’ guy. After talking with him and
then doing some more thinking today, I have better positioned the S60
OSS Browser in my model of the mobile world.

We are not consumers. We are active participants in our life.
The mobile has taken communication and sharing to a new level for
humanity. The two most used features of a mobile phone are voice and
text messaging – communication. Unfortunately, most mobile service
providers think all we want to do is sit and watch TV,
download ring tones and wall papers, and, yes, browse information. Eh,
that doesn’t fit my idea of the Mobile Lifestyle.

If the
survivors of Web 1.0 and the poster children of Web 2.0 are any
indication, even on the PC-based Web, people aren’t just passively
consuming. Ebay and Amazon are not about consuming, but connecting via
an enabling platform. Google is not about browsing, but about seeking
and finding answers to our questions. Flickr is not about browsing, but
about sharing images of our life. On-line journals and logs are not about browsing, but about communicating intimately.

Then what is the fascination with mobile browsing? I want mobile cognecting, sharing, finding, interacting.

I
admitted to Franklin that I really don’t think it’s about full access
to Web content, but full access to Web services. I think a full browser
on a mobile phone that enables browsing of full Web sites is nice. It’s
part of a continuum from simple sites that are mobile-savvy, to
mobile-friendly (they don’t break on a mobile browser), to all the
millions of old and current sites that ignore the mobile.
And, it’s surely a better option than .mobi
(which Franklin and I didn’t discuss) and maybe transcoders (which we
did discuss and Franklin is aware of the legal issues brought up by
Scott Rafer and Dave Harper).

Furthermore,
my head lately has been in low-end, mass-market phones with simpler
browsers, so full browsing is not part of my daily thoughts. On my
mind, when it comes to the mobile browser, are the kind of services,
like Winksite, that create a helping
intermediary
between the capabilities of my phone and the services I
want to reach. On my mind, is not the 10s of million S60 phones, but
the 100s of millions basic phones with no access to Web services.

Words of wisdom
Franklin and I have had many discussions of this sort over the past years and I can sometimes see his influence in my thoughts. Nonetheless,
it pleased me when, once again, it turned out we were of the same mind
– his vision is to have the best mobile browser out there so that
mobiles no longer have to be second-class citizens on the Web, so that
mobile users can interact with all the services out there, so that, as more
mobiles actively and interactively use the Web, the Web will have to
become mobile-savvy.

He envisions a two-prong approach of 1)
evangelizing this versatile browser and what it can do – convincing
folks to become mobile-savvy, and 2) increase the numbers of mobile
phones accessing the Web in general – to wake people up to the rapidly
growing
numbers of phones accessing their sites and hence convince folks to become mobile-savvy.

And,
in response to some of my desires as to how I would like to interact
with the Web from my mobile (and not just browse), he let me in on some
current and future developments. I’m not sure what is public of not, so
just a tease right now – sorry. Suffice it to say, Franklin is part of
a cool team that has a long-term vision of how mobile phones will
interact with Web services in the future.

Model holding steady
I can still say that I am not so keen on mobile browsing. Nonetheless, my idea of
the mobile Web is well within the plans Franklin and the browser
team have. Indeed, the browser team is not really building a browser, but a
tool to interact with the Web, with the same freedom and flexibility I
have from my PC.

Maybe Franklin and team should no longer call it a ‘browser’, that’s too
passive and misleading, considering their vision. What could it be
called? Hmm. 🙂

*I call a ‘blindspot’ anything I don’t get or
think others don’t get, basically trying understand why I don’t agree
with the general consensus. Click here for other blindspots I have
written about. Sadly, I have a long list of other blindspots of mine
that I still want to write about.

Martin asks: Porting FON into a Symbian 3G Wifi Phone

A friend of mine pointed out that Martin Varsavsky is thinking of how to combine WiFi mobile phones with his FON movement.

It really depends on what he has in mind. Is it to turn the phone into a FON bases station? The wifi on the phone doesn’t actually work in that manner, as far as I can tell (I have an N93).

The WiFi is really only for the phone to connect to a WiFi network. If anyone were to connect to the phone, I am pretty sure that the phone would not be able to tunnel that to the 3G network – so no badwidth sharing, really.

Hence, there may two ways at least to approach this:
1 – make the WLAN phone FON-friendly, such that it connects to FON basestations easily and provides all the FON services to the phone.
2 – make the phone FON-friendly such that the phone can share its 3G connection via WiFi. Eh, there are cost issues and such, but it would be interesting to share bandwidth in this way. Normally, the phone will share bandwidth with one device over bluetooth. Here, you could have multiple WiFi devices sharing the phone’s bandwidth.

So, it comes back to what he has in mind.

Martin?

Link [via Dirk H]: Martin Varsavsky | English.

Does anyone know how we could port FON functionality say chillispot into a Symbian 3G/WiFi phone like the N80? If so please write to me. I see a great potential in taking the Fon Movement into mobile phones and have 3G to WiFi converters. Just look at the WiFi Alliance site and see how many gadgets have WiFi while there are almost no gadgets that are not phones with 3G.

Darla Mack is asking for 4 Things from me

Ok. So Darla has dumped the 4 Things meme on me. I’m in a good mood, so I’ll join the game.

Four jobs I have had in my life:
1. Tech at MIT
2. Volunteer at Boston’s Museum of Science
3. Independent Editorial Consultant and Writer
4. Dreamer (everyday!)

Four movies I would watch over and over:
1. The Matrix
2. The Incredibles
3. Sinbad (from Dream Works)
4. uh, those were the ones at home. i’m sure there are others. and darla, start with these, your list is, uh, could be upgraded (grease? sheesh!). 🙂

Four places I have lived in (considering I have moved every 2-3 years for the last 20):
1. All over Massachusetts
2. Rio de Janeiro, Brasil
3. Helsinki, Finland
4. Valley Stream, NY (Long Island)

Four TV shows I love to watch (don’t watch TV anymore, but here they were):
1. ER
2. CSI (original)
3. Star Trek: Next Generation
4. Babylon V
5. I also used to like wathcing Zoom and Arthur with the kids when they were wee

Four books I would recommend:
1. The Lord of the Rings
2. Pullman’s ‘Dark Materials’ series
3. Snow Crash, by Neal Stephenson
4. And for a hat tip to business writers, anything by Guy Kawasaki

Four places I have been on vacation (too many places, so these are the ones I remember fondly):   
1. France (all over)
2. Egypt (cruise up the Nile)
3. Guadeloupe (twice, I want to live there)
4. Adirondacks of New York (great Appalachian nature)

Web sites I visit daily (most of them are here):
1. Darla Mack (my only must-visit tech site)
2. My friends on Flickr (especially hugovk)
3. Janne, Matt, and Chris – thinkers (and stinkers) I highly respect
4. Boston.com
sheesh, there are a lot i visit daily…

Four of my favorite foods:
1. French Fries
2. Beer
3. Burgers
4. Tart fruit (strawberries, pineapples, kiwi, etc.)

Four places I would rather be right now:
1. Somewhere along the Mediterranean
2. Massachusetts
3. Exploring the deep past
4. In the arms of my family

Four friends I think will respond:

not sure, since I don’t like forwarding these types of memes. so feel free to do it and let me know! (sorri!)

From the Nokia press site: Nokia decides not to go forward with Sanyo CDMA partnership and plans broad restructuring of its CDMA business

Looks like Sanyo and Nokia in the end could not agree on some issues (Disclaimer: Just like most of you, I am not privvy to anything regarding this announcement, so don’t ask me for more info.).

I don’t know what this really means for Nokia’s CDMA line, but there’s sure to be more turbulence ahead for that division.

I have a lot of opinions in this space, as I have watched the CDMA guys try to find their groove. But, alas, I don’t think it’s appropriate for me to say anything further at this time other than ‘Best of luck, Nokia CDMA’.

What a tease. 😛

Link: Nokia – ShowPressRelease.

Espoo, Finland – Nokia announced today that it will not be forming the new CDMA device company with SANYO it preliminarily announced on February 14, 2006. Nokia decided not to pursue its earlier plan as it concluded the terms and conditions of the proposed partnership were not satisfactory and in the best interests of Nokia’s long term success. In addition to an already financially prohibitive CDMA ecosystem in general, recent developments may indicate that the CDMA emerging markets business case is looking more challenging.

Exploring the Depths of Thought and the Inquiry into Our Spirit:* Aula Movement 2006

Marko Ahtisaari and Jyri Engeström, with the help of a team of wonderful people I was fortunate to meet, organized a two-day event in Helsinki called Aula Movement 2006.

Aula is an ‘open community of people working in different fields of life including science, art, business, government, and NGOs.’ It is run by Marko and Jyri and a few other enlightened people here in Helsinki. I must shamefully admit that I am not half (quarter!) as involved as I would like to be – I find the mix of thinking and doing closer to my academic (philosophic?) ways.

Aula Movement 2006 was ‘about the direction of society, culture and technology.’ The theme tended towards where mobility meets the Web, ‘the overlapping of the physical and the virtual, and the social movement-like nature of new technologies.’

I was fortunate enough to attend the first day and the tail end sliver of the second day. And, as happens any time I enter the Marko-Jyri Zone, I left enlightened, my head full of new thoughts, old thoughts pulled up and shaken up again, having met and listened to the gaggle of clever and active people who are normally part of Marko and Jyri’s world.

The first day was open to the general public. As happens when I go to local events that are tech (especially, mobile) oriented, I met a bunch of great folks I already know (great seein’ ya!). There were also some folks I was surprised to see there (I have an idea why, now). Nonetheless, even though they seemed out of place, it was a needed eye-opener for them.

The speakers that day were Clay Shirky, Alistair Curtis, Martin Varsavsky, and Joi Ito. Interspersed were some music and interpretive dance pieces – to clear the mental palate, as it were, cool and interesting like lime sorbet between courses of a meal.

Clay spoke about how the open source movement allows coders to sample the full range of possibilities and fail often in a cost effective way. To the biologist geek in me, it’s a simple Darwinian selection process. What I think Clay left out, though I know he understands, is that the way you sample the space of the possible, your selection mechanism, necessarily restricts the kinds of things you come up with. So, to me, the open source process is good, but I want to see such broad sampling in the mobile world, where things are multi-part, more complex, and have larger hurdles than simply a coder with a PC.

Alistair, Chief of Design, Nokia, I am embarrassed to say, I sort of tuned out. There were too many corporate slides. And he droned on about how Nokia Design was connecting with user emotion. I am sure Alistair is a nice guy. But if you are passionate about something, especially designing experiences, which is the soul of the company, then it should show. My problem was with his lack of enthusiasm in the presentation. I keep coming back to the idea that corporate leaders should be measured on how enthusiastic and infectious they are. Case in point: Martin Varsavsky.

Martin is the Chief Fonero (I mentioned him before). He introduced the audience to FON, his grass-roots WiFi community. He was also launching FON formally in Finland (Marko is Chief Fonero, Finland). In terms of enthusiasm, Martin exuded it. He was like a stand-up comic, bringing reality to what he was saying, not being afraid to make a bold statement, and telling it in the true way of a believer. Anina has a few more things to say about Martin, and even has him on video.

Joi was the last speaker of the day. He is a breed apart, living a few years ahead of the regular world. Listening to him is like tunneling the mind-waves of how folks will live and communicate in the future. For those who don’t follow Joi, his last big trend bet was blogging. He was an early investor and supporter of Six Apart, introducing me to them (with Marko), when they were a still small company (and I have watched them blossom incredibly). Now, he’s hooked on World of Warcraft – an immersive online 3-D role-playing world. It may sound geeky, but, along with a bunch of folks he roped in or met there, he is discovering new things about how people interact, form groups, establish their own identity, and create. There have been some notes in the news about WoW (and a similar world called Second Life) being the New Golf. But, Joi clearly shows that it is actually the New Church. In golf, you get together to play a game then disband, and it’s the way to make connections in business. In contrast, in church, people get together, volunteer, in an ad-hoc fashion to accomplish certain tasks for the community or other individuals in a totally selfless fashion, and make meaningful, supportive, and lasting connections. WoW is about social reputation, accomplishing tasks in a non-authoritative environment, volunteering for the benefit of others, sharing, and so on. An interesting development to follow, for sure.

Later that evening there was a great dinner, where I had the good fortune to catch up with old acquaintances (great seein’ you guys, too!) and meet some new people I hope to meet again, like Arwen O’Reilly and her pal (name?), both from Make Magazine. Together with the inestimable Ulla-Maaria (Jyri’s other half), we talked a lot about making things and, what Ulla-Maaria champions, crafting (read her Crafter’s Manifesto!). I also spoke with Tyler Brûlé about his evolving ideas of a mobile TV channel. I also finally met Marko’s other half and partner in crime, Lisa Sounio, and some of her friends. Great bunch all.

The dinner party then moved to a local designer hotel and the conversation flowed on for hours. I met and chatted with, among others, a bunch of designers, met and spoke with Thomas Madsen-Mygdal of reboot fame, spoke a lot about the future of floor-ball with Fred, caught up with Loïc (dude, we gots to hit the road again – it’s what we’re good at!), and had a good chat on many things with Ross. While I have forgotten the details (for various reasons), I picked up a bunch of ideas and gossip that are now brewing in my head.

The second day was by invitation only and I wasn’t invited (I guess I’m not enough of a mover or shaker). But, there was a dinner in the evening, to which Anina was invited and I was her date (though I still felt a bit of a party-crasher, hence my uncharacteristic mousy-ness). Before dinner there was a talk titled ‘Tokyo Blues’ by Nurri Kim, about how she went around Tokyo and created cool photos of the many uses of a common blue tarp material all across Tokyo. Really cool.
After that, Cory Doctorow gave a great and enthusiastic talk about self-determination (I commented on a part, earlier this week). Loïc has a video of the talk – watch it.

With all the talks completed, Thomas Crampton gave a great summary of the whole thing (is it written down anywhere? it was really great.), so I was able to get a (teasing!) taste of what day 2 was like. Amazing. Too bad I missed it. Maybe next time.

We then were entertained by a great dance troupe, Gruppen Fyra, who did this amazing piece called ‘Pendulum’. Really hit the right buttons in my brain and soul.

After that we retired to a nice dinner with DJ music and great conversation. All in all, Marko and Jyri and gang know how to feed the mind and spirit. I am blessed to know them and share a small part in the things they do.

For more coverage on the event, check out more links here

*In good self-referential fashion, I borrowed the title from myself.

Milestone for car


Milestone for car
Originally uploaded by schickr.

Tue 20.06.2006 13.50 20062006(01) I am the kind obsessed with finding patterns in everything, such as strings of numbers, clouds, machine sounds, and license plates.

For a few years (mostly because I now have a camera phone) I’ve been capturing different patterns on my car’s odometer. I missed some recent good ones and thought I was going to miss this last one today. But my children encourage my eccentricities and my wife played along and they captured this great pair of readings.

Heh.

Milestone for car


Milestone for car
Originally uploaded by schickr.

Tue 20.06.2006 13.31 20062006 I am the kind obsessed with finding patterns in everything, such as strings of numbers, clouds, machine sounds, and license plates.

For a few years (mostly because I now have a camera phone) I’ve been capturing different patterns on my car’s odometer. I missed some recent good ones and thought I was going to miss this last one today. But my children encourage my eccentricities and my wife played along and they captured this great pair of readings.

Heh.